Larsen's Fish Market56 Basin RdChilmark, MA 02535(508) 645-2680 Seafood MarketsPrice range: $$( 197 Yelp! reviews )Lookout Tavern8 Seaview AveOak Bluffs, MA 02557(508) 696-9844 Seafood | American (New) | PubsPrice range: $$( 752 Yelp! reviews )The Net Result79 Beach RdVineyard Haven, MA 02568(508) 693-6071 Seafood | Seafood Markets | Sushi BarsPrice range: $$( 337 Yelp! reviews )Menemsha Fish Market54 Basin RdChilmark, MA 02535(508) 645-2282 Seafood Markets | SeafoodPrice range: $$( 118 Yelp! reviews )The Fish House17 Airport RdEdgartown, MA 02539(508) 693-0055 Seafood Markets | Seafood | ButcherPrice range: ( 17 Yelp! reviews )The Barking Claw29 Locust StFalmouth, MA 02540(508) 233-2774 Hot Dogs | Seafood | Food StandsPrice range: $$( 117 Yelp! reviews )Edgartown Seafood138 Cooke StEdgartown, MA 02539(508) 627-3791 Seafood MarketsPrice range: $$( 36 Yelp! reviews )The Covington52 Main StEdgartown, MA 02539(508) 627-7678 American (New) | Bars | SeafoodPrice range: $$$( 114 Yelp! reviews )19 Raw19 Church StEdgartown, MA 02539(774) 224-0550 Seafood | Wine BarsPrice range: $$( 179 Yelp! reviews )Sandy's Fish and Chips5 Martin RdVineyard Haven, MA 02568(508) 693-1220 Seafood | Fish & ChipsPrice range: $$( 35 Yelp! reviews )John's Fish Market5 Martin RdVineyard Haven, MA 02568(508) 693-1220 Seafood MarketsPrice range: $$( 20 Yelp! reviews )Beach Road Restaurant79 Beach RdVineyard Haven, MA 02568(508) 693-8582 Seafood | American (New) | Wine BarsPrice range: $$$( 90 Yelp! reviews )Square-Rigger Restaurant225 Vineyard Haven RdEdgartown, MA 02539(508) 627-9968 Seafood | American (Traditional) | BarsPrice range: $$$( 89 Yelp! reviews )Waterside Market82 Main StVineyard Haven, MA 02568(508) 693-8899 Breakfast & Brunch | Sandwiches | SaladPrice range: $$( 181 Yelp! reviews )Nomans15 Island Inn RdOak Bluffs, MA 02557(508) 338-2474 American (Traditional) | Beer GardensPrice range: ( 91 Yelp! reviews )Marthas Vineyard Chowder Company9 Oak Bluffs AveOak Bluffs, MA 02557(508) 696-3000 Seafood | Fish & ChipsPrice range: $$( 385 Yelp! reviews )The Clam Man15 Boxwood CirFalmouth, MA 02540(508) 548-6044 Seafood MarketsPrice range: $$( 55 Yelp! reviews )Coop de Ville12 Circuit Ave ExtensionOak Bluffs, MA 02557(508) 693-3420 American (Traditional) | Seafood | BarsPrice range: $$( 123 Yelp! reviews )Offshore Ale30 Kennebec AveOak Bluffs, MA 02557(508) 693-2626 Breweries | American (New) | BarsPrice range: $$( 435 Yelp! reviews )Merrill's on the Waterfront36 Homer's WharfNew Bedford, MA 02740(508) 997-7010 SeafoodPrice range: $$( 62 Yelp! reviews )Lobsterville Bar & Grille8 Circuit Ave ExtentionOak Bluffs, MA 02557(508) 696-0099 Bars | SeafoodPrice range: $$( 115 Yelp! reviews )Rosewater Market & Take Away20 S Summer StEdgartown, MA 02539(508) 627-1270 Salad | Coffee & Tea | SandwichesPrice range: $$( 104 Yelp! reviews )Chilmark Tavern9 State RdChilmark, MA 02535(508) 645-9400 American (New) | Vegetarian | DessertsPrice range: $$$$( 89 Yelp! reviews )The Port Hunter55 Main StEdgartown, MA 02539(508) 627-7747 Seafood | Cocktail BarsPrice range: $$( 230 Yelp! reviews )Menemsha Galley515 N RdChilmark, MA 02535(508) 645-9819 Burgers | Food StandsPrice range: $$( 70 Yelp! reviews )Home Port Restaurant512 N RdMenemsha, MA 02552(508) 645-2679 SeafoodPrice range: $$$( 144 Yelp! reviews )Water Street Kitchen56 Water StWoods Hole, Falmouth, MA 02543(508) 540-5656 Bars | American (New) | SeafoodPrice range: $$$( 144 Yelp! reviews )L'etoile Restaurant22 N Water StEdgartown, MA 02539(508) 627-5187 FrenchPrice range: $$$( 128 Yelp! reviews )Seafood Shanty31 Dock StEdgartown, MA 02539(508) 627-8622 Seafood | American (New) | Sushi BarsPrice range: $$( 588 Yelp! reviews )Falmouth Fish Market157 Teaticket State RteTeaticket, MA 02536(508) 540-0045 Seafood | Seafood MarketsPrice range: $$( 75 Yelp! reviews )Cape Fish & Lobster Company626 W Main StHyannis, MA 02601(508) 771-1122 Seafood MarketsPrice range: $$$( 34 Yelp! reviews )Nancy's29 Lake AveOak Bluffs, MA 02557(508) 693-0006 Seafood | Burgers | VegetarianPrice range: $$( 455 Yelp! reviews )MacPhails18 Dock StEdgartown, MA 02539(508) 939-3090 Coffee & Tea | Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt | SandwichesPrice range: $( 42 Yelp! reviews )Among The Flowers Cafe17 Mayhew LnEdgartown, MA 02539(508) 627-3233 Breakfast & Brunch | Cafes | SeafoodPrice range: $$( 258 Yelp! reviews )The Red Cat Kitchen6 Circuit AveOak Bluffs, MA 02557(508) 696-6040 American (New) | Seafood | BarsPrice range: $$$( 296 Yelp! reviews )Chef Amy's Food Truck61 Beach RdVineyard Haven, MA 02568(508) 857-8783 Food Trucks | Soul Food | SeafoodPrice range: ( 9 Yelp! reviews )State Road Restaurant688 State RdWest Tisbury, MA 02575(508) 693-8582 American (New) | Wine BarsPrice range: $$$( 187 Yelp! reviews )Linda Jean's Restaurant25 Circuit AveOak Bluffs, MA 02557(508) 693-4093 Breakfast & Brunch | Seafood | WafflesPrice range: $$( 331 Yelp! reviews )The Black Dog Tavern20 Beach St ExtVineyard Haven, MA 02568(508) 693-9223 Seafood | American (Traditional)Price range: $$( 478 Yelp! reviews )Quarterdeck29 Dock StEdgartown, MA 02539(508) 627-5346 Seafood | Burgers | Hot DogsPrice range: $$( 37 Yelp! reviews )Cliffhangers21 Aquinnah CirAquinnah, MA 02535(508) 955-9163 Food Stands | Breakfast & Brunch | American (Traditional)Price range: ( 3 Yelp! reviews )The Aquinnah Shop Restaurant27 Aquinnah CirAquinnah, MA 02535(508) 645-3867 SeafoodPrice range: $$( 92 Yelp! reviews )The Quarterdeck Restaurant164 Main StFalmouth, MA 02540(508) 548-9900 Seafood | American (Traditional)Price range: $$( 499 Yelp! reviews )The Newes From America Pub23 Kelley StEdgartown, MA 02539(508) 627-4397 American (Traditional) | PubsPrice range: $$( 269 Yelp! reviews )Detente15 Winter StUnit 3Nevin Square(508) 627-8810 Wine Bars | American (New)Price range: $$$( 92 Yelp! reviews )Vineyard Caribbean Cuisine7 Circuit Avenue ExtensionOak Bluffs, MA 02557(508) 338-7077 CaribbeanPrice range: ( 44 Yelp! reviews )The Raw Bar259 Shore DrMashpee, MA 02649(774) 228-2327 Bars | Seafood | Live/Raw FoodPrice range: $$( 249 Yelp! reviews )Edgartown Meat & Fish240 Edgartown Vineyard Haven RdEdgartown, MA 02539(508) 627-6200 Seafood Markets | Meat Shops | CafesPrice range: $$( 44 Yelp! reviews )Bettini131 N Water StHarbor View HotelEdgartown, MA 02539(508) 627-3761 Seafood | Breakfast & Brunch | American (New)Price range: ( 64 Yelp! reviews )Spanky's Clam Shack & Seaside Saloon138 Ocean StHyannis, MA 02601(508) 771-2770 SeafoodPrice range: $$( 917 Yelp! reviews )