Atria137 Main StEdgartown, MA 02539(508) 627-5850 New American | Wine BarsPrice range: $$$( 263 Yelp! reviews )Rosewater Market & Take Away20 S Summer StEdgartown, MA 02539(508) 627-1270 Salad | Coffee & Tea | SandwichesPrice range: $$( 115 Yelp! reviews )Edgartown Diner65 Main StEdgartown, MA 02539(508) 627-9337 Breakfast & Brunch | Diners | AmericanPrice range: $$( 92 Yelp! reviews )The Terrace at The Charlotte Inn27 S Summer StEdgartown, MA 02539(508) 627-6227 New American | Salad | FrenchPrice range: $$$$( 56 Yelp! reviews )Seafood Shanty31 Dock StEdgartown, MA 02539(508) 627-8622 Seafood | New American | Sushi BarsPrice range: $$( 643 Yelp! reviews )Atlantic Fish & Chop House2 Main StEdgartown, MA 02539(508) 627-7001 Seafood | SteakhousesPrice range: $$$( 508 Yelp! reviews )