Larsen's Fish Market56 Basin RdChilmark, MA 02535(508) 645-2680 Seafood MarketsPrice range: $$( 215 Yelp! reviews )Menemsha Fish Market54 Basin RdChilmark, MA 02535(508) 645-2282 Seafood Markets | SeafoodPrice range: $$( 126 Yelp! reviews )Sashimi Shack58 Basin RdAquinnah, MA 02535(774) 563-3394 Seafood | Live/Raw FoodPrice range: ( 1 Yelp! reviews )Chilmark Tavern9 State RdChilmark, MA 02535(508) 645-9400 New American | Vegetarian | DessertsPrice range: $$$$( 99 Yelp! reviews )Menemsha Galley515 N RdChilmark, MA 02535(508) 645-9819 Burgers | Food StandsPrice range: $$( 71 Yelp! reviews )Home Port Restaurant512 N RdMenemsha, MA 02552(508) 645-2679 SeafoodPrice range: $$$( 157 Yelp! reviews )State Road688 State RdWest Tisbury, MA 02575(508) 693-8582 New American | Wine BarsPrice range: $$$( 198 Yelp! reviews )Beach Plum Inn & Restaurant50 Beach Plum LnChilmark, MA 02535(508) 645-9454 Hotels | Venues & Event Spaces | Breakfast & BrunchPrice range: $$$$( 89 Yelp! reviews )