Orange Peel Bakery22 State RdTown of Aquinnah, MA 02535(508) 645-2025 BakeriesPrice range: $$( 35 Yelp! reviews )Chilmark General Store7 State RdChilmark, MA 02535(508) 645-3739 Grocery | Pizza | Coffee & TeaPrice range: $$( 65 Yelp! reviews )Chilmark Tavern9 State RdChilmark, MA 02535(508) 645-9400 New American | Vegetarian | DessertsPrice range: $$$$( 99 Yelp! reviews )Island Fresh Pizza395 State RdThe Little Shopping CenterTisbury, MA 02568(508) 338-2764 PizzaPrice range: ( 23 Yelp! reviews )Fella's Take Out479 State RdWest Tisbury, MA 02575(508) 693-6924 Pizza | Sandwiches | BarbequePrice range: $$( 4 Yelp! reviews )State Road688 State RdWest Tisbury, MA 02575(508) 693-8582 New American | Wine BarsPrice range: $$$( 198 Yelp! reviews )Vineyard Take Out479 State RdWest Tisbury, MA 02568(508) 693-6924 Sandwiches | Pizza | Breakfast & BrunchPrice range: ( 1 Yelp! reviews )